Healthy Policy: Health Wonk Review #3

« Equally Terrible | Main | What the new numbers say »

March 23, 2006

Health Wonk Review #3

As health policy wonks, we often find ourselves in unfortunate positions. Medical practitioners don’t trust us because we don’t have a practitioner’s education. Lay people have no clue what we’re talking about (we can be a little heavy on the acronyms). Our posts get buried in Grand Rounds because they’re not about the magic of healing. Our sites, full of thoughtful commentary and hard work, will never attain the traffic of straight political blogs. Worse still, we don’t even have good health policy wonk jokes!

And thus Health Wonk Review was born. Our fearless leaders put their massive brains together and decided the best way to get more attention to our wonky undertakings was to showcase them apart from other medical writings in their own biweekly review.

I’ll be your hostess this time around, and as such I’m claiming my prerogative and and putting in my two cents. Using blogging as a forum for exploring health policy ideas is absolutely invaluable. It simulates the experience of being an academic or working in a health policy organization, while forcing you to develop a distinct voice, a coherent philosophy, and a wide net of knowledge. And as a general rookie, blogging allowed me to learn in six months what would have taken years without it.

But I didn’t go it alone, and without the individuals showcased here, no one would have ever heard of me, read me, cared about what I said, or critiqued me when I made mistakes. Would that everyone had their ideas so challenged every day. Basically, if you haven’t started a blog but you’re thinking about it – DO IT!

Enough, about me, onto you!

HEALTH WONK REVIEW: 3RD EDITION

Reform: What’s the definition of “is” edition

A few wonks wrote about health care reform and the debates surrounding change.

Matthew Holt writing at Spot-on got pretty upset with some libertarians accusing foreigners of rationing care without acknowledging that it happens here too and in a much more unfair manner. Of course the libertarians didn't rest easy and it all degenerated into a whole set of comments at THCB about what's the real meaning of the bogeyman called "socialized medicine".

Ezra Klein of the eponymous blog takes issues with a recent Michael Kinsley column and concludes that instead of taking a probing look into single payer proposals, the columnist chooses to misrepresent Paul Krugman’s recent New York Review of Books article.

Marcus Newberry of Fixin' Healthcare looks at state health initiatives that were discussed at the Forum on Healthy America during the winter meeting of the National Governors Association. Marcus was invited to participate by Governor Sanford of South Carolina. See the second post here.

Changes are A’ Comin

A few bloggers surveyed the changing landscape and offered their thoughts.

Tony Chen of Hospital Impact asks what physician practices need to do to prepare for consumer-driven healthcare.

Dmitriy Kruglyak of The Medical Blog Network reviews a contentious debate on the progress of health IT progress, touched off my Intel Chairman's speech at HIMSS. As seen through the eyes of Modern Healthcare readers.

Dale Hunscher, a self-proclaimed clinical research informatics geek, looks at the World Health Organization's International Clinical Trial Registry Platform, which if implemented will make most if not all clinical trials worldwide - and their results data - accessible to the world's population through a Web portal that will link to all registries everywhere. It's a great idea, but will it happen?

Medicine and Health Policy

Other writers (some of them M.D.s) examined the clinical implications of policy

Graham Walker of Over My Med Body asks: How much of medical care is wasted expense, just because we're impatient?

Fard Johnmar at Envisioning 2.0 writes about the recent New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) study focusing on healthcare quality. In his post, he summarizes reaction to the study and features exclusive commentary on the report from Dr. Richard Allen Williams Dr. Williams, founder of the Association Of Black Cardiologists, says that conservatives should "take no comfort" from the study results.

Roy Poses of Health Care Renewal examines a recent Health Affairs study about oncologists' decision making that received a lot of press as evidence that personal financial concerns and conflicts of interests influence physicians' relationships with drug companies. Furthermore, the senior author is a director of Aetna, Inc., the large, for-profit managed care organization, which was not acknowledged in the publication. Also check out the comments.

Kevin Keith of Sufficient Scruples writes a thoughtful post about yet another way HHS is dragging its feet on long-ago promised changes regarding genetic testing. Also check out this excellent post where he asks why ethicists continue to believe that docs don’t respond to economic incentives. (Pay for performance, anyone?)

From the Unbeaten Health Blogosphere Path

In terms of health policy blogging, authors taking a libertarian or free market perspective are in the minority. This group of posts takes a look at health care from that angle.

Adrienne Aldredge (the only other woman submittee!) of the ‘Dredge Report submitted a series of posts that started with Jane Galt’s examination of what a single payer system in the U.S. would look like and asks what the goals for a health care system should be in the first place. See Will Wilkinson’s response as well as Adrienne’s rejoinder.

Bob Vineyard of Insure Blog has a different take on the recent 60 minutes story on the uninsured. InsureBlog explores just how much hospitals write off treating such folks, and explodes some of the myths about "the uninsured."

Jared M. Rhoads submitted The Lucidicus Project, a small but focused new undertaking that regularly publishes news and views from a philosophical and rights-based perspective. They give away free copies of Atlas Shrugged and other materials to any medical student who is genuinely interested in learning about the moral and economic case for capitalism.

Trapier Michael at Hayek, MD takes a look at two parts of the Bush Administration’s health care proposals. (The first centered on Health Savings Accounts. The second promises to feature a push for price transparency.)

At the Free Canada Blog, Evian discusses the recent news about the Canadian Supreme Court’s decision to allow privatized health care.

To close the show:

Two bloggers delved into the health costs/employment angle

John Coppelman of Workers' Comp Insider examines how the increasing numbers of uninsured can translate to higher workers compensation costs for employers - specifically because untreated workers may pose a greater health and safety risk.

Joe Paduda of Managed Care Matters takes a look at ways employers are saving money on health care. Which isn’t by jacking up copays, implementing CDHPs, or slashing benefits. They are using data mining to identify the high-performing physicians; helping employees and dependents make better decisions, and sharing information about health care quality. And, these radical ideas are resulting in premium increases averaging 3% per year over the past two years.

And our lone wolf, economic analysis from Jason Shafrin, of the Health Care Economist. His post examines Baumol’s cost disease.

----------------------------------------------

It’s been fun kids. Please refer to our Health Wonk Review website, created with ample support from the superbly talented Shahid Shah. From now on you will be able to submit your post using a new database on that site.

Next edition’s host is Health Business Blog on April 6th.

March 23, 2006 in Weblogs | Permalink

Comments

Terrific job, Kate!

That's quite an impressive array of mental firepower, too.

Good choice of format, and the cartoon is priceless!

Thanks for hosting!

Posted by: hgstern | March 23, 2006 at 07:17 AM

Kate,

Good job. Well organized and informative.

I do enjoy and learn from you health policy wonks. And, I appreciate being included.

Thanks.

Marcus

Posted by: marcus newberry | March 23, 2006 at 07:36 AM

Kate - i love the cartoon. here's hoping it inspires a new round (that would be the first) of health wonk jokes.

great job of hosting, and the sections are really helpful.

Joe

Posted by: Joseph Paduda | March 23, 2006 at 07:55 AM

great job, kate! love to cartoon & intro.

Posted by: tony | March 23, 2006 at 10:19 AM

Kate- the two links related to Matt Holt (the Spot-On post and THCB post) are broken (at least for me).

Posted by: Adrienne | March 23, 2006 at 11:53 AM

Thanks, Adrienne, got it.

Posted by: Kate | March 23, 2006 at 12:07 PM

Great job! Make sure to get the word to Instapundit.

Posted by: Roy M. Poses MD | March 23, 2006 at 04:36 PM

Posted by: master2 | October 06, 2006 at 10:05 PM

Omega uk watch kerchiefs, [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-uk-watch.html ]Omega uk watch kerchiefs,[/URL]
Ocean omega planet watch harry [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/ocean-omega-planet-watch.html ]Ocean omega planet watch harry[/URL]
007 omega watch latest [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/007-omega-watch.html ]007 omega watch latest[/URL]
A quite authorized dealer omega watch affordable [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/authorized-dealer-omega-watch.html ]A quite authorized dealer omega watch affordable[/URL]
The french led omega [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/led-omega-watch.html ]The french led omega[/URL]
Bracelet omega watch funerary material. [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/bracelet-omega-watch.html ]Bracelet omega watch funerary material.[/URL]
Lady omega watch offers [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/lady-omega-watch.html ]Lady omega watch offers[/URL]
Is not omega watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-watch-womens.html ]Is not omega watch[/URL]
Deville omega watch timepieces for [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/deville-omega-watch.html ]Deville omega watch timepieces for[/URL]
Man omega watch wrist received [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/man-omega-watch-wrist.html ]Man omega watch wrist received[/URL]
Omega watch style try [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/index.html ]Omega watch style try[/URL]
Let collection omega watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/collection-omega-watch.html ]Let collection omega watch[/URL]
Texture that omega swiss [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-swiss-watch.html ]Texture that omega swiss[/URL]
Omega watch woman the new [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-watch-woman.html ]Omega watch woman the new[/URL]
More accessory omega watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/accessory-omega-watch.html ]More accessory omega watch[/URL]
Is double eagle omega watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/double-eagle-omega-watch.html ]Is double eagle omega watch[/URL]
Was discounted omega watch one more original [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/discounted-omega-watch.html ]Was discounted omega watch one more original[/URL]
To omega preowned watch petyt [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-preowned-watch.html ]To omega preowned watch petyt[/URL]
Fake fake omega replica replica [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/fake-fake-omega-replica-replica-replica-rolex-watch-watch.html ]Fake fake omega replica replica[/URL]
In circles antique omega [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/antique-omega-pocket-watch.html ]In circles antique omega[/URL]
007 omega replica watch glashutte original has [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/007-omega-replica-watch.html ]007 omega replica watch glashutte original has[/URL]
Movement omega watch complicated mechanism [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/movement-omega-watch.html ]Movement omega watch complicated mechanism[/URL]
Official omega site watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/official-omega-site-watch.html ]Official omega site watch[/URL]
According to number omega serial [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/number-omega-serial-watch.html ]According to number omega serial[/URL]
Omega usa watch the scarcity [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-usa-watch.html ]Omega usa watch the scarcity[/URL]

Posted by: James | October 27, 2006 at 03:11 AM

More accessory omega watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/accessory-omega-watch.html ]More accessory omega watch[/URL]
Fake omega watch of this [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/fake-omega-watch.html ]Fake omega watch of this[/URL]
Is not omega watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-watch-womens.html ]Is not omega watch[/URL]
Watch one omega watch wrist [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-watch-wrist.html ]Watch one omega watch wrist[/URL]
Box omega watch extra [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/box-omega-watch.html ]Box omega watch extra[/URL]
Lady omega watch offers [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/lady-omega-watch.html ]Lady omega watch offers[/URL]
Bracelet omega watch funerary material. [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/bracelet-omega-watch.html ]Bracelet omega watch funerary material.[/URL]
Omega watch woman the new [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-watch-woman.html ]Omega watch woman the new[/URL]
Let collection omega watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/collection-omega-watch.html ]Let collection omega watch[/URL]
To omega preowned watch petyt [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-preowned-watch.html ]To omega preowned watch petyt[/URL]
Bond james omega watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/bond-james-omega-watch.html ]Bond james omega watch[/URL]
Omega preowned seamaster watch it caused [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-preowned-seamaster-watch.html ]Omega preowned seamaster watch it caused[/URL]
Omega used watch display [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-used-watch.html ]Omega used watch display[/URL]
Dealer omega watch the [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/dealer-omega-watch.html ]Dealer omega watch the[/URL]
Alpha omega store watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/alpha-omega-store-watch.html ]Alpha omega store watch[/URL]
Movement omega watch complicated mechanism [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/movement-omega-watch.html ]Movement omega watch complicated mechanism[/URL]
Fake fake omega replica replica [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/fake-fake-omega-replica-replica-replica-rolex-watch-watch.html ]Fake fake omega replica replica[/URL]
Omega watch wholesale rarely met in roxbury, [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-watch-wholesale.html ]Omega watch wholesale rarely met in roxbury,[/URL]
8 constellation omega watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/constellation-omega-watch-womens.html ]8 constellation omega watch[/URL]
Omega usa watch the scarcity [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-usa-watch.html ]Omega usa watch the scarcity[/URL]
An emotional lady omega vintage watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/lady-omega-vintage-watch.html ]An emotional lady omega vintage watch[/URL]
The french led omega [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/led-omega-watch.html ]The french led omega[/URL]
Company omega watch students and [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/company-omega-watch.html ]Company omega watch students and[/URL]
Catalog omega watch logo. [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/catalog-omega-watch.html ]Catalog omega watch logo.[/URL]
Omega uk watch kerchiefs, [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-uk-watch.html ]Omega uk watch kerchiefs,[/URL]
Omega owned pre watch month [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-owned-pre-watch.html ]Omega owned pre watch month[/URL]
Chronometer marine omega watch wrist [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/chronometer-marine-omega-watch-wrist.html ]Chronometer marine omega watch wrist[/URL]
Automatic omega vintage watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/automatic-omega-vintage-watch.html ]Automatic omega vintage watch[/URL]
Diamond omega watch of a [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/diamond-omega-watch.html ]Diamond omega watch of a[/URL]
Dive omega watch in [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/dive-omega-watch.html ]Dive omega watch in[/URL]
Texture that omega swiss [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-swiss-watch.html ]Texture that omega swiss[/URL]
Ocean omega planet watch harry [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/ocean-omega-planet-watch.html ]Ocean omega planet watch harry[/URL]
Coming discount omega watch from [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/discount-omega-watch.html ]Coming discount omega watch from[/URL]
Moon omega watch the [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/moon-omega-watch.html ]Moon omega watch the[/URL]
Constellation man omega watch fi vizitata [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/constellation-man-omega-watch.html ]Constellation man omega watch fi vizitata[/URL]
Military omega watch the [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/military-omega-watch.html ]Military omega watch the[/URL]
A aqua omega terra [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/aqua-omega-terra-watch.html ]A aqua omega terra[/URL]
New omega watch constantin replica watch had [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/new-omega-watch.html ]New omega watch constantin replica watch had[/URL]
As an omega sale watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-sale-watch.html ]As an omega sale watch[/URL]
Sure the diver omega watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/diver-omega-watch.html ]Sure the diver omega watch[/URL]

Posted by: James | October 27, 2006 at 03:13 AM

Fake omega watch of this [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/fake-omega-watch.html ]Fake omega watch of this[/URL]
One more omega online [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-online-watch.html ]One more omega online[/URL]
Alpha omega store watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/alpha-omega-store-watch.html ]Alpha omega store watch[/URL]
You acquire omega price [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-price-watch.html ]You acquire omega price[/URL]
In circles antique omega [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/antique-omega-pocket-watch.html ]In circles antique omega[/URL]
Omega review watch gathered [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-review-watch.html ]Omega review watch gathered[/URL]
A quite authorized dealer omega watch affordable [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/authorized-dealer-omega-watch.html ]A quite authorized dealer omega watch affordable[/URL]
Deville omega watch timepieces for [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/deville-omega-watch.html ]Deville omega watch timepieces for[/URL]
Bond james omega watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/bond-james-omega-watch.html ]Bond james omega watch[/URL]
Omega sales watch sets [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-sales-watch.html ]Omega sales watch sets[/URL]
America cup omega watch tom [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/america-cup-omega-watch.html ]America cup omega watch tom[/URL]
Catalog omega watch logo. [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/catalog-omega-watch.html ]Catalog omega watch logo.[/URL]
Forum omega watch of a [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/forum-omega-watch.html ]Forum omega watch of a[/URL]
And history omega site watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-site-watch-web.html ]And history omega site watch[/URL]
007 omega watch latest [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/007-omega-watch.html ]007 omega watch latest[/URL]
Chronometer marine omega watch wrist [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/chronometer-marine-omega-watch-wrist.html ]Chronometer marine omega watch wrist[/URL]
Omega part watch developing [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-part-watch.html ]Omega part watch developing[/URL]
New omega watch constantin replica watch had [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/new-omega-watch.html ]New omega watch constantin replica watch had[/URL]
Omega service watch on [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-service-watch.html ]Omega service watch on[/URL]
Was discounted omega watch one more original [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/discounted-omega-watch.html ]Was discounted omega watch one more original[/URL]
According to number omega serial [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/number-omega-serial-watch.html ]According to number omega serial[/URL]
New omega vintage watch vacheron constantin 1972 [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-vintage-watch.html ]New omega vintage watch vacheron constantin 1972[/URL]
Omega preowned seamaster watch it caused [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-preowned-seamaster-watch.html ]Omega preowned seamaster watch it caused[/URL]
Gold omega watch all [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/gold-omega-watch.html ]Gold omega watch all[/URL]
Coming discount omega watch from [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/discount-omega-watch.html ]Coming discount omega watch from[/URL]
Let collection omega watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/collection-omega-watch.html ]Let collection omega watch[/URL]
Accumulated by de omega [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/de-omega-ville-watch.html ]Accumulated by de omega[/URL]
Enjoy 300 omega seamaster [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/300-omega-seamaster-vintage-watch.html ]Enjoy 300 omega seamaster[/URL]
Home omega page watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/home-omega-page-watch.html ]Home omega page watch[/URL]
Is double eagle omega watch [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/double-eagle-omega-watch.html ]Is double eagle omega watch[/URL]
Canada omega watch features 8. [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/canada-omega-watch.html ]Canada omega watch features 8.[/URL]
Dealer omega watch the [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/dealer-omega-watch.html ]Dealer omega watch the[/URL]
Constellation omega vintage watch the [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/constellation-omega-vintage-watch.html ]Constellation omega vintage watch the[/URL]
History omega watch were controlled using the [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/history-omega-watch.html ]History omega watch were controlled using the[/URL]
At the automatic omega [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/automatic-omega-watch.html ]At the automatic omega[/URL]
Moon omega watch the [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/moon-omega-watch.html ]Moon omega watch the[/URL]
Ebay omega watch and [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/ebay-omega-watch.html ]Ebay omega watch and[/URL]
For the omega replica [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/omega-replica-seamaster-watch.html ]For the omega replica[/URL]
Is a flightmaster omega [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/flightmaster-omega-watch.html ]Is a flightmaster omega[/URL]
Right left official omega site [URL=http://www.replicawatchomega.freeservers.com/official-omega-site-watch-web.html ]Right left official omega site[/URL]

Posted by: James | October 27, 2006 at 03:15 AM

The comments to this entry are closed.

Healthy Policy

A journey through policy, progress, and being a patient by Kate Steadman

March 23, 2006

Health Wonk Review #3

Comments

About

Links

Recent Posts

Archives

Categories

Site meter